The Gilded Age Season 4, Episode 3, “Ain’t That Good News” Spoilers Ahead
In every way that it matters, “Ain’t That Good News” is the kind of exceptional episode that makes The Gilded Age an astounding treat on TV. There’s no show that’s currently airing right now that could make me sob so hard over one scene that I have to pause, only to then make me hold my stomach and laugh. It’s a testament to the writing and each actor continuously bringing their best to the surface, but also, it’s again proof of what happens when you allow characters to just exist in a space where the ordinary gets to come alive beautifully.
It’s not hard to appreciate the small moments in this show, and as much as the fandom loves to poke fun at the detail that nothing happens, we get continuous proof in every episode that the “nothing” is actually everything.
Wedding Bells Ring for Peggy and William in The Gilded Age Season 4, Episode 3
I couldn’t have pictured a more perfect wedding episode for Peggy and William. From every moment leading up to it to the actual ceremony itself, my tear ducts are grateful for the ride the show takes us on. But more importantly, it’s such a beautiful moment for the character, and it’s comforting that the show allows us to see every minute of it. For a second, I was concerned that might not be the case, but instead, there’s not a single beat throughout the episode that doesn’t feel earned or full of depth.
But before we get into the wedding portion, it’s how the show gives us substantial conversations that really stick the landing—starting with Marian’s choice to give her something old. There aren’t many depictions of strong female friendships on the show when there’s more biting animosity toward each other than not, but from the very beginning, Peggy and Marian have looked out for each other.
The fact that Marian kept the train ticket as a reminder of Peggy’s kindness and that the two have constantly been an anchor to each other are the types of lovely details that feel specifically crucial on the night of Peggy’s wedding. Because friendships are just as important as romantic love, and these two women have time and again proven that they have steadfast support in their corner. They have a friend who’ll be there through the ups and downs, without judgment. What’s also so precious is that you could see just how important they are to each other in Louisa Jacobson and Denée Benton’s performances. There’s a lot of love here, and it’s the kind they’ll carry with them when they’re old and grey, held in a sacred place.
Next comes the conversation with Peggy and her mom, with Audra McDonald making me straight up weep again. The way Dorothy has stood by and supported her daughter through everything is so important when we see the polar opposite from her mother-in-law. There’s nothing more obvious than the fact that this time, the Scotts aren’t going to let anything get in the way of their daughter’s happiness, and sometimes that’s an honest conversation as well as a gift that says, I’m always thinking of you.
Peggy’s hopes and dreams require the kind of support her mother is giving her right at this second, and nothing else matters beyond that. In a gorgeously heartfelt scene, we get the kind of momentous conversation that’s going to stay with me for a long, long time.
And now for the ceremony: you see, if I loved this scene less, I might be able to talk about it more. There’s so much longing and warmth in the performances that Benton and Jordan Donica deliver. How they show us with every glance that this is a moment both of them will never take for granted, and it’s a gift they can’t quite believe they get to have. The fact that William continues to choose her over his mother’s every action and was also willing not to have her at the wedding after everything she pulled is so crucial.
It’s the kind of proof we need to know that for William, no one matters the way Peggy does. For William, her happiness and her comfort—including a new house close to her cousin—are what matters. She’s his entire world, and we see that clear as day in The Gilded Age Season 4, Episode 3, “Ain’t That Good News.” We see it in the decision that the two of them make to jump over the broom, hand in hand, while the choir sings. Their union is between two equal partners, and there’s no doubt about this fact at the wedding. None whatsoever. There isn’t a lot we can trust in, but we can trust the fact that Peggy and William will love each other through every hurdle, in sickness and in health, and whatever challenge rises before them.
How Long Will George Hide His Addiction from Bertha?

While it was a little less obvious before, and the show’s primary focus was on bringing the two of them somewhat to the same page as we got in “You Won’t Hear Me Beg,” George is now fully experiencing withdrawals and hiding it from Bertha. It’s unclear how long this will last, but what isn’t unclear is that he should’ve trusted her from the beginning. He should’ve confided in her about the Rockefeller deal because every bit of good that might come soon is going to be because of her.
It’s also easy to wonder how much of his addiction The Gilded Age will actually explore when shows tend to shy away from storylines like it. It’s a heavy subject to take on, but it’s also one the series writers can be trusted with at this point. More importantly, I hope Bertha is aware of it sooner rather than later, if no one else. Because otherwise, it’s likely going to get so much worse than what we’re seeing here.
I’m often so floored by Carrie Coon’s vulnerability and the way she pleads with George. She’ll rarely ever be vulnerable with anyone else, but she isn’t afraid to tell her husband that she can’t bear the thought of losing him again. The way she softens a bit when she asks him if he’ll come to her room. The way she takes charge and immediately helps with the Rockefeller deal by working the donation to Spellman’s Seminary, the school funded by Laura Spellman Rockefeller, Rockefeller’s wife. The way she talks to Larry. There’s nothing Bertha wouldn’t do to help out, which, in turn, having her realize what’s going on is going to give us some of the best performances, and I, for one, can’t wait.
Agnes’ Presidential Dinner Goes to Bertha Russell
CHRISTINE BARANSKI—you legend. It’s certainly not fun to see anyone piss our queen off, but it’s always sensational to see the performances Baranski brings when Agnes is tested. And at the end of the episode, Agnes is tested. With a not-so-great article about her and kinder words about Ada’s curtains, Agnes’ presidential dinner is now being hosted at the Russell house. A whole new form of salt on the wounds.
I appreciate that Agnes is still involved in the process despite the fact that it won’t be in her home, but still—we’re in for a wild, wild time. Things are about to get even more hilarious and likely awful before they’re even a little better, but it was good to have a few moments of joy before we’re thrust back into the delicious drama that makes The Gilded Age flare to life.
All Things New
Can we bring back the Jack who was scared of artichokes because he’s now eating oysters and flirting with women who aren’t Bridget, and I’m not sure how to cope with it. What I am more intrigued with, though, is the idea of Oscar potentially meeting another man? Things are also going swimmingly for our girl Aurora, who’s got a new beau, and it even looks like Ada might be into Mr. Harris (Dennis Haysbert). Oliver is barely holding anything together, but none of us can judge him because we’re all hanging by threads ourselves—I know I am.
The Gilded Age Season 4, Episode 3, “Ain’t That Good News” is sure to propel us toward a tumultuous ride next week because there’s no way we can get this much joy without struggling later. Still, at least everyone looked great throughout.
Further Thoughts
- THE HOUSE!!! It’s so perfect for Peggy, and this scene of William showing it to her is everything I could’ve wanted and more.
- Oliver and the suitcases is now the greatest, most relatable meme of all time.
- Agnes 😩😂
- George’s nightmare leading to a brief beat of hurt/comfort is all I could’ve wanted between these two.
- I love that Bertha’s confronting Larry, even when all the men in her life are making ridiculous decisions left and right.
- “I nearly lost you once and I’m not taking that chance again.”
- Jack being all fancy and eating oysters is sending me, but so are the plates being straight up empty.
- BERTHA BABE THIS BLUE DRESS.
- AURORA HAS A NEW BOYFRIEND!! GET IT, GIRLY!!!
- The article on his Agnes. I will fight.
- “I find often the lord is too lenient.” I hate to use his name in vain, but like, she has a point.
- Now, they’re hosting the diner
- The way George’s eyes light up every time their grandson is mentioned is so special to me.
- Like, see, George, this is why you involve Bertha.
- “And with ice!” I’m screaming. I love it here.
- While I didn’t mention it up top, I love the idea of Peggy going to see her mother-in-law to have this conversation about why it’s so crucial that they start things off on the right foot. How she’d never want to put a wedge between her and William, and that it’s so important for her to show up to the wedding. Peggy’s grace continues to floor me in every way.
- Where did this auction come from!?
- Agnes, babe, you love Peggy; stop whining.
- Never getting over the train ticket, to be honest 😭
- “We’ve come so far.” “We’re New Yorkers” MY GIRLS!!!
- “Just remind her that mothers-in-laws don’t live forever.” AGNES. I CANNOT.
- GOSH I LOVE PEGGY’S MOM WITH MY WHOLE HEART.
- EVERYONE IS MAKING ME SOB 😭😭
- “I love you, papa.” My heart’s in pieces, actually. 😭
- Marian popping her little head out of the aisle. That’s her bestie!!
- The look on Agnes’ face 🥺
- I had to pause because I couldn’t see through my tears.
- THE BROOM!!!
- Christine Baranski is a FORCE.
- “No, I called the secretary on our telephone.” I’M HOWLING.
- They’re literally all comedians. This show is a comedy.
- “Let it be enough that I’m home.” But it’s not, bro. Go sleep with your wife. She is always the key.
- “I just want to go to bed and wake up in 1881 before anyone even heard of Bertha Russell!” What a line. Give Christine Baranski her Emmy right this second.
Now streaming on HBO Max: What are your thoughts on The Gilded Age Season 4, Episode 3, “Ain’t That Good News?” Let us know in the comments below.
First Featured Image Credit: ©Photograph by Karolina Wojtasik/HBO






