
Percy Jackson Season 3, Episode 1, “My Rescue Operation Goes Very Wrong” Spoilers Ahead
There’s so much in Percy Jackson and the Olympians that leaves me floored, and at the top of the list are the performances. The way that each actor distinctly brings their respective character to life does so in a way that not only elevates the words on the page, but unveils endless layers that result in excellent material to analyze. And while Season 3 has just started, Walker Scobell has already delivered one of my favorite performances of the year with Percy’s reaction to Annabeth being taken.
Context is key here in more ways than one. As someone who’s read the books, I know where Percy’s feelings stand at this exact moment in The Titan’s Curse, even if he himself doesn’t. I can also recognize ever-growing feelings before the character even admits to them aloud. Simultaneously, Percy and Annabeth are two people who care about each other deeply. They’re best friends—Annabeth says it herself. There’s deep-seated respect between them, but there’s also a lot of love.
Percy Jackson Season 3, Episode 1 Underscores Just How Deeply Percy Cares for Annabeth

For Percy, there’s also immense, unshakable fear alongside his guilt, and Scobell brings each of these emotions to life beautifully in a single shot. (I have chills just thinking about it.) The tears he’s holding back with the realization that it’s him and Thalia who were targets is one thing, but the way he slowly processes the guilt of losing Annabeth is another. But let’s take it back for a second: While dancing, Percy denies that he’d burn Olympus to the ground for her, but we all know that’s the farthest thing from the truth. That initial declaration wasn’t the careless result of a bad—it was the most sincere truth, flaring straight from his heart. But adults fumble under pressure, so it’s not even remotely shocking that Percy does, too. Tension rises as a result of this conversation—and Annabeth rightfully walks away from him—but the bigger emotions come later. They’re more staggering in the characters’ actions, not their words.
It’s also imperative to know that, yes, Annabeth would fight for both Percy and Thalia. She’d jump on top of the Manticore to protect him, in the same way he’d do anything for her, no matter how hard he botched their heart-to-heart by putting his foot in his mouth earlier. When push comes to shove, they’re both going to give their all, but that’s exactly what makes Percy’s reaction to her fall so gutting. The way Percy screams for me? An actual stab wound might hurt less.
Because Percy’s reaction isn’t just a friend reacting to a friend. It’s a human being reacting for his person—someone so profoundly treasured in his heart that he himself can’t even begin to grasp the magnitude of her importance. Because it’s a reaction that not even grown adults can evoke as brilliantly sometimes. The way he tries to catch his breath, control his rage, and process the weight of what’s happened all at once is no small feat. It’s bigger than him, and it’s bigger than any quest they can take on. In general, he’s a kid with big feelings, but Percy Jackson Season 3, Episode 1, “My Rescue Operation Goes Very Wrong,” reminds us that his capacity for love is his greatest strength. His desire to protect those he cares about—Annabeth specifically—is everything to him. It continues to be the reason his heart is consistently on his sleeve.
This is just the beginning for Walker Scobell this season. It’s easy to overdo a scene like this when a character’s having big feelings in a confusing situation, but the way he shows us Percy’s slow, deeply human realization is what floors me. Because it’s so natural and so achingly profound to wear a thousand emotions at once like this—pain, guilt, fear, love, anger, confusion. There’s not a single haunting thought that isn’t crossing Percy’s mind as he grapples with the fall and Annabeth’s disappearance. He’s standing before another goddess, but no part of him cares.
The way the gravity of Percy’s emotions rattles out of Scobell’s voice as he clearly tries to hold everything in makes this scene even more daunting, because Grover’s full-on crying (with an excellent performance from Aryan Simhadri), and so is Thalia (with Tamara Smart bringing her A-game), but Percy’s shattering in a completely different way. The hurt and guilt aren’t just palpable in his line deliveries, but in the way he carries himself. Percy Jackson isn’t going to be okay until Annabeth Chase is safe again, and to convey the depth of those emotions in such a small scene is something I’m going to be thinking about for a long, long time.
Now streaming on Disney+: What are your thoughts on Percy’s reaction to Annabeth’s fall in Percy Jackson Season 3, Episode 1? Let us know in the comments below.
First Featured Image Credit: ©Disney+
