
Bridgerton Season 4 Part 1 Spoilers Ahead
Four seasons in, it’s safe to say that Netflix’s Bridgerton is quite the behemoth. The Regency romance series is big enough at this point that it’s generated an abundance of its own traditions, or what I like to call “Bridgerton staples.”
Whether it’s the show’s use of classical covers of modern songs, the naming of one episode per season after the respective Julia Quinn novel, or regardless of the romantic pitfalls each lead couple endures, the guaranteed happily ever after, there are plenty of consistent features that fans can look forward to with each season.
One such tradition — and my personal favorite — is the inclusion of at least one so-called “swings scene” between the two “outsider” Bridgerton siblings, Benedict and Eloise. At the time of writing, the first four episodes of Season 4, which tell the love story of Benedict and nobleman’s bastard-turned-servant Sophie Baek, have aired, with the back half of the season set to drop on February 26.
In this season’s second episode, “Time Transfixed,” Bridgerton keeps the tradition alive by presenting us with yet another swings scene between Benedict and Eloise, the fifth of the series overall. (The past swings scenes occur in the Season 1 episodes “Shock and Delight” and “Art of the Swoon,” Season 2’s “The Viscount Who Loved Me,” and Season 3’s “Into the Light.”)
But it’s different this time. Admittedly, the differences aren’t so obvious upon first glance — the siblings do once again meet, seemingly spontaneously, at the backyard swings for a nighttime confessional, but subtle choices made with this iteration’s writing and blocking suggest an important shift has occurred in Benedict and Eloise’s dynamic, and one that we’re meant to pay attention to.
For starters, the scene opens with Benedict having already taken up residence on the swings, before Eloise comes out to join him. This is contrary to the four previous scenes, in which Eloise is always the one that Benedict finds already out in the yard.
The second difference between this scene and those that came before it is the blocking. When viewed from behind, Benedict is seated on the left swing, while Eloise is on the right, whereas normally it’s the opposite configuration (Eloise on the left, Benedict on the right). I know this sounds incredibly minor, but given that this is the fifth occurrence of such a scene, and yet the only time the siblings’ positions have switched, I can’t help but feel that this change is intentional.
Finally, this scene is the only one that ends with Benedict getting up to leave. Conversely, in every other swings scene that we’ve witnessed, Benedict and Eloise reach an understanding of sorts by scene’s end, and then most of the time just stay outside and enjoy each other’s company (in one instance, Eloise gets up to leave, but it’s with both she and Benedict in good spirits). One of them never leaves the other behind when their problems remain unresolved. Until now.
I make a point of highlighting these three simple, yet suspicious, differences in Season 4’s swings scene because I think the show is trying to communicate to us that, for the first time in four seasons, Benedict’s and Eloise’s paths have diverged.
They are no longer — at least, not currently — on the same page when it comes to their opinions on society and specifically the marriage mart, and Eloise basically says as much after Benedict correctly deduces that Eloise has been avoiding him.
“Have you been displeased with me?” Benedict asks his sister as she takes a seat on the adjacent swing. “I have not seen much of you lately.”
“It took you long enough to notice,” Eloise scolds him. “You realize you were cast out of the clubhouse?”
This, apparently, is news to Benedict: “Was I in a club?” he inquires, and Eloise tells him, “We were. I thought we would be unyielding together, with regard to marriage, but you have crossed over to the other side.”
This is yet another unique aspect of Season 4’s swings scene. In the past, whenever either sibling has sought solace in the familiar wooden swings, it’s been because of some inner turmoil or interpersonal conflict. Their woes have been with their mother, or with one of their other siblings, or with their best friend (in Eloise’s case), or with society as a whole — but never with each other.
This season, though, things have shifted. And Eloise knows it. When Benedict tells her, “Well, I am not getting married anytime soon,” Eloise cuts in with the truth: “But you wanted to. To the glove lady.” And Benedict doesn’t deny it, confessing to Eloise that yes, he did think it could be possible to marry his Lady in Silver from their mother’s masquerade in “The Waltz.”
It’s this acknowledgment that spurs Benedict on to then reveal his reason for heading out to the swings tonight: he believes the Lady in Silver is hiding from him and rejecting his attempts to reconnect with her because she is not interested in him. “You and I both know I am not the Bridgerton anyone should give their heart to,” he tells Eloise. “The unserious one. The… the rake. The free spirit.”
He then dejectedly asks Eloise if she might consider letting him back into their aforementioned clubhouse, a request that Eloise correctly identifies as a bad omen for her brother’s current state of mind. Sure enough, to cope with his crushing disappointment, Benedict’s plan is to go on the regency equivalent of a bender. As mentioned earlier, he then gets up from his swing, seemingly unbothered about leaving Eloise behind. Before he goes, Eloise begs him, “Please! Do not leave me in Mama’s hands.”
Benedict tells her their mother might surprise her, and these parting words to Eloise are the only time in the entire scene that he actually addresses her concerns. He’s been solely focused on his own up until this point, which is once again a deviation from the dynamic on display in all their other moments on the swings.
Normally, both Benedict and Eloise are struggling with something when they independently head out to the swings. The beauty of a typical swings scene, then, is how they so easily confide in each other and end up feeling at least marginally better about everything — not to mention unconditionally loved and supported by a kindred spirit/sibling.
In Season 4, neither Eloise nor Benedict feels better after having spoken to each other out on the swings. What’s historically been their safe space isn’t so safe anymore — at least, it’s no longer as effective at alleviating the worst of their problems as it once was, nor is it at reaffirming the strength of their bond.
So what does this all mean? Are my beloved swings scenes officially a thing of the past? Does this spell the end for my favorite Bridgerton tradition? Not at all.
As I said earlier, the reason I bothered pointing out the slight differences between this most recent swings scene and all its predecessors is that I believe Bridgerton has very deliberately made these changes in order to create an overall sense of disconnect between Benedict and Eloise — and it’s working.
Watching this scene for the first time, I was left feeling strangely unsatisfied, a foreign concept when it comes to the part of the show that I normally most look forward to. It was only after rewatching it and comparing it to the other iterations that I noticed the aforementioned differences, which is how I realized that this particular swings scene feels unfinished and unresolved because it’s supposed to.
Because of how early this scene comes in Benedict’s leading season of Bridgerton, it makes sense that he’s not yet at a place to have his biggest problems alleviated by one conversation with his sister. Similarly, Eloise is nowhere near ready to get to the root of what’s really giving her grief right now, and she won’t be for a while — honestly, probably not until she eventually has her own season (whether that’s Season 5 or 6, who knows for sure?).
So, then where do we go from here? To me, the answer is simple — we need to resolve what’s left lingering between Benedict and Eloise, and the best way to do that is to get them back out to the swings before season’s end. We can’t let this weird tension between them carry into the next season without being addressed.
Benedict and Eloise need a second swings scene in Season 4 Part 2, and I’m expecting such a follow-up to come in the finale, ideally after Benedict and Sophie have achieved their romantic resolution. For this scene, I have a few specific requests for how it should ultimately play out.
First, I want Eloise to be the one who’s already out on the swings when Benedict finds her. Especially if this scene is to happen late in the finale, it makes sense for Benedict to be in a far better, far more assured position now than he was in Part 1, and certainly a better one than Eloise still finds herself in. This choice in the setup of the scene would be to specifically reflect that evolution.
Then, I want it to be made explicitly clear in the dialogue that Benedict came out to the swings to check on Eloise, not because he himself has any pressing problems to stew in. It should be acknowledged onscreen that the only thing left on Benedict’s mind at this point in his story is Eloise, since he’s finally figured things out with Sophie; the only interpersonal conflict he has left to resolve is the one between him and Eloise.
I should also note that I’d like Benedict and Eloise to be back in their usual seating arrangement for this scene (Eloise on the left, Benedict on the right) to signal to the audience that just because some things are changing, not everything has to.
Finally, in order to emphasize the role of confidant that Benedict still very much intends to play in Eloise’s life, I’d like for this swings scene to end with Benedict encouraging Eloise to get off the swings and come back inside with him. Seeing the two of them walk back to Bridgerton House together would be a lovely way to visually communicate that Benedict is still going to be there for his sister and support her. And, at the same time, seeing them leave the swings behind (at least for now), instead of one or both of them lingering outside in purgatory, would symbolize that they’ve outgrown the swings but are still moving forward, and more importantly, they’re doing so together.
And who knows? Once Eloise’s season rolls around, maybe the time will come to revisit this location and all that it represents for the siblings. Or maybe by then, Eloise will realize that she and Benedict’s old way of dealing with their challenges (seeking solace in the backyard swings late at night) could use some updating. If Benedict could achieve a more sustainable solution to his inner turmoil, maybe she could, too.
Because in the end, it was never really about the swings at all — it was about Benedict and Eloise.
Bridgerton Season 4, Part 1 is now streaming on Netflix.
First Featured Image Credit: ©Netflix

