Scene Breakdown: Maddie and Eddie Finally Talk About Buck in 9-1-1’s ‘Et Tu?’

Maddie and Eddie finally talk in 911 Season 10, Episode 6.

If there’s one thing fans of ABC’s procedural drama 9-1-1 have been waiting for — aside from, of course, a particular fan-favorite ship going canon — it’s a proper scene between Eddie Diaz and Maddie Han. Both characters joined the show back in Season 2, and yet in the nine years since, they’ve never truly had a real one-on-one conversation on-screen.

That is, until now.

Season 10’s “Et Tu?” gives fans the long-awaited, highly anticipated interaction, and it’s also something the actors themselves, Jennifer Love Hewitt and Ryan Guzman, have been clamoring for (Hewitt posted a celebratory Instagram reel with Guzman when the scene was finally filmed earlier this fall).

One of the biggest reasons fans have been so desperate to see these two particular characters have a scene together is because of their respective relationships with Evan “Buck” Buckley. Buck is Maddie’s younger brother, and he’s also Eddie’s firefighting coworker and best friend. The past nine years of the show have made it clear that Maddie and Eddie are the two people Buck is closest to, so of course the appetite has always been there for them to share notes at some point.

Maddie holds the door open for Eddie in 911 on ABC 10x06.
©ABC

When they finally talk in 9-1-1 Season 10, Episode 6, “Et Tu?”, in a scene taking place in Maddie’s home, it’s hardly a surprise that Buck — and the care of his biological child, Theo — is the primary topic of conversation. As revealed in last week’s “Who’s Your Daddy?”, Eddie recently started fostering Theo after Buck himself elected to stop fostering him out of concern for traumatizing the child.

For context, Theo is the four-year-old son of Buck’s friends Connor and Kameron, who reached out in Season 6 about Buck becoming their sperm donor. In the penultimate episode of Season 9, Theo becomes an orphan when his parents die in a car accident that Buck and his colleagues respond to, and Season 9’s final shot is Buck welcoming Theo into his home as his foster son.

The start of the current season focused on the challenges Buck encountered due to this arrangement, culminating in Buck’s decision to give Theo up in the opening scene of “Who’s Your Daddy?” That episode ends with Eddie, who has been privy to Buck’s struggles and expressed concern about Theo’s care a few episodes earlier, electing to foster Theo himself instead of letting him get lost in the system again. Needless to say, Buck’s reaction upon discovering this decision is anything but positive.

This week, “Et Tu?” sees Eddie bring Theo to Maddie’s house for a playdate with her daughter, Jee-Yun, and Maddie seizes the opportunity for her and Eddie to talk about this whole situation.

Theo and Jee playing together in 911 on ABC Season 10.
©ABC

Eddie is initially unsure if he’s even welcome in the home right now — Maddie has to tell him, “You can come in” before he willingly crosses the threshold — and it’s an immediate indicator that this first on-screen conversation isn’t going to play out the way some fans have been hoping for all these years.

And this, in my opinion, is exactly what makes it so interesting to watch.

Longtime viewers will know that Maddie’s and Eddie’s relative histories with Buck are very different now in Season 10 than they were in Season 2, particularly in Eddie’s case. However, something that has remained consistent throughout is just how deeply they both care about Buck and want what’s best for him. Therefore, when they finally talk one-on-one about Buck, it’s fascinating to see how their individual biases influence how they each approach the conversation.

In Maddie’s case, her and Buck’s nine-year age gap and their tumultuous upbringing led to her assuming a pseudo-maternal role in Buck’s life. This role is one that, like it or not, still manifests from time to time in both of their adulthoods, and it’s what makes her particularly protective at this moment when her baby brother is struggling.

Conversely, for Eddie, he’s coming at this conversation from the perspective of someone who has spent years in an extremely co-dependent relationship with Buck, particularly when it comes to the care of Eddie’s son, Christopher (now a teenager). Eddie is more than familiar with Buck’s ability to be a good parental figure, as he’s done it almost the entire time they’ve known each other and is also the legal guardian of Christopher in Eddie’s will (a revelation that came in the Season 4 finale, “Survivors”).

Eddie watches the kids play in 911 on ABC Season 10, Episode 6.
©ABC

Early in this scene in “Et Tu?”, while Maddie makes coffee in the kitchen, Eddie just watches Theo and Jee play together, an obviously fond look on his face. He initially rejects Maddie’s offer of a cup of coffee, but Maddie pushes back with a “No, you’re gonna have coffee.” For the first time in the history of the show, we see Maddie turn her protective big sister tendencies against Eddie.

Eddie, of course, picks up on Maddie’s tone immediately (and if he somehow hadn’t, Maddie’s pointed, no-nonsense look is impossible to miss) and leaves the kids to join her in the kitchen. He’s not getting out of this big talk Maddie so clearly wants to have.

“Yeah, I really appreciate you letting Theo come over,” Eddie starts, to which Maddie says, “Yeah, of course. Jee loves Theo. We all love Theo.” Again, just like the look she gave Eddie mere moments ago, this comment is pointed. She doesn’t need to say more for Eddie to understand the underlying accusation.

Maddie and talk about Theo and Buck in 911 Season 10, Episode 6.
©ABC

“You know I’m not doing this to hurt Buck,” he tells her, and Maddie doesn’t think he is, but she does wonder if maybe Eddie’s trying to teach her brother a lesson. “No, I’m trying to give him another chance,” he explains. “Him and Theo. At least this way, with me, the kid’s world isn’t upended again.“ He goes on to elaborate how this new arrangement means Theo can continue to visit Maddie’s kids and spend time with other people he’s become close with, like Buck and Eddie’s coworker Hen Wilson and her wife, Karen. “And, eventually, when [Buck] heals enough, [Theo] can have an actual relationship with his biological father.”

This revelation from Eddie is, in my opinion, the entire reason this scene exists. When Buck found out about Eddie’s decision last episode, Buck’s reaction removed any opportunity for Eddie to explain his line of thinking, which meant that we, as the audience, didn’t get to hear it either. Now, in him speaking with Maddie, we come to understand the deeper reasoning behind Eddie’s choice (which goes beyond just wanting Theo to have stability).

Eddie in 911 on ABC holds a cup of coffee while talking to Maddie in Season 10.
©ABC

Maddie understands this, too. “Look, I don’t fault your decision,” she tells Eddie. “I actually think that it’s quite remarkable, but you have to see it from Buck’s perspective.” And Eddie does see it — as he tells Maddie, “He thinks I’m judging him.”

Maddie challenges him on that: “You’re not?” Eddie takes a moment to collect his thoughts, then gets into how he’s not trying to teach Buck a lesson; he’s “trying to save him from learning one. Some choices… you can’t take back.” There’s obvious lived experience laced in his tone here, and we as viewers know all about Eddie’s history and certain parenting missteps he’s made in the past that he regrets.

“Yeah, he hates himself for what he did,” Maddie acknowledges about Buck now. “But the person he would usually talk to about that…” She trails off, the implication clear: Buck would normally talk to Eddie, because Eddie is Buck’s person (however you want to define it). Eddie understands this, too, and recognizes that right now they can’t talk because “he sees me as the enemy.” He’s still worried about Buck, of course, and asks Maddie if her brother is currently spiraling. Maddie tells him, “No, he’s just… sad. Maybe a little lost.”

Maddie in 911 Season 10, Episode 6.
©ABC

Eddie laments that he doesn’t know how to help Buck right now, and it’s a sentiment that feels very reminiscent of one he expressed directly to Buck in Season 8’s “Don’t Drink the Water,” an episode centered around the characters’ grief over the death of their fire captain, Bobby Nash. “You’ve been spiraling since the funeral, and no one knows how to talk to you about it,” Eddie rightfully accuses Buck at the time. He was concerned about Buck then, and he’s concerned about him now, regardless of the underlying reason.

This inaugural Maddie-Eddie scene comes to a close with Maddie advising Eddie to “just focus on Theo. Buck will figure it out for himself.” One look at Eddie’s face, though, makes it clear that this advice doesn’t sit right with him, and it’s yet another indicator of the difference between these two characters’ respective relationships with Buck.

At this moment in time, this is what Maddie believes is best for her brother, but Eddie, who holds a different perspective than Buck’s sister/maternal figure, doesn’t agree. These are the two people who know Buck better than anyone else, but right now they differ on what they think Buck needs to get through this.

Eddie looking sad in 911 on ABC Season 10, Episode 6.
©ABC

So, who is right? And who is wrong? Who truly knows Buck best?

In short? It depends.

The very reason why this Maddie and Eddie relationship dynamic is so layered is also why this, their first real scene together, is so ripe for analysis. The past nine seasons of 9-1-1 have provided several examples of Maddie knowing exactly what will help Buck, but they’ve also shown us several other instances of it being Eddie who has the best understanding of Buck’s needs at a particular moment.

When it really comes down to it, Maddie and Eddie are two people Buck is extremely lucky to have in his life, and the moments (like now) where they disagree just serve to emphasize the importance of him maintaining both of these distinct relationships. It’s just like in an earlier season of the show (Season 5’s “Home and Away”), when Buck disagrees with the approach Maddie’s partner, Howard “Chimney” Han (another of Buck and Eddie’s coworkers), is taking to handle a particular crisis Maddie is facing.

“He just doesn’t know her the way I do,” Buck complains to Eddie about Chimney. “Or,” Eddie counters, “You don’t know her the way he does.”

While fans — myself included — would certainly have welcomed a Maddie and Eddie scene prior to Season 10, a conversation like this never needed to happen between them until now.

What are your thoughts on Maddie and Eddie’s conversation in 9-1-1 Season 10, Episode 6, “Et Tu?” Let us know in the comments below.
First Featured Image Credit: ©ABC

Advertisements

Leave a Reply