Audrey Hall has come undone. During All Creatures Great and Small Season 5, rare glimpses have reminded viewers that her son, Edward, remains at sea. In “Pair Bond,” Audrey reveals to Bosworth that constant worry makes her feel “like a smashed pot that’s been glued back together.” Yet, within her home and her found family, Mrs. Hall has remained the solid heart of Skeldale House. After learning, however, that a Japanese attack has sunk Edward’s ship, she becomes increasingly brittle in “All God’s Creatures.”
Audrey tries to conceal her unraveling until an emergency sends her racing to Siegfried’s surgery. Expecting to find the compassionate caregiver willing to go to great lengths to save Bingo, Mrs. Hall instead finds a pragmatic vet. Mr. Farnon glibly refers to a death sentence as “a simple injection.” Perhaps, recalling the unmourned fox in “Pair Bond,” Audrey recognizes that humans do not assign equal importance to all lives. After heatedly accusing Siegfried of playing God, Audrey cracks as she laments the unfairness of a hierarchy within Creation. She feebly repeats that Siegfried “shouldn’t…” leaving viewers to fill in the blank. We and Siegfried understand that Audrey is begging him not to squash her hope in the possibility of surviving against the odds, for the fox or for Edward. Mrs. Hall lifts her arms in resignation before tearfully leaving the exam room. She appears to feel hopeless about changing the outcome.
Audrey soon discovers that her plea has not fallen on deaf ears. Her unsolicited confession in response provides what may be the most heart-wrenching scene in a series known for its poignant moments.
Showing Mercy
Fresh off her visit with Paddy Grainger, where she pressed the young sailor to confirm her worst fears, Mrs. Hall seeks solitude. The opening frame positions viewers inside the shed, looking out through the half door. We see Mrs. Hall arrive at the door, still wearing her coat and gloves. Audrey’s expression shows she is initially startled and upset at what she discovers. The angle does not permit viewers to know what she sees, keeping the focus on Audrey as she enters gingerly. As she looks around, Mrs. Hall’s face takes on a softer, astonished expression. Her gaze shifts back to its original focus, but still, the camera does not reveal what or to whom she fixes her questioning eyes; instead, it pans to reveal the fox resting comfortably in a hay-lined crate.
A cut to Audrey and Siegfried, with the top of the crate in the foreground, reveals he has been there watching and waiting. His voice is now gentle, not clinical. As he updates Audrey, she releases an audible sigh. It feels like the first time she has exhaled since the early minutes of “All God’s Creatures.” Siegfried’s voice breaks as he assures Audrey he’s done all he can to save the fox. The frame cuts to a wider view, showing both standing with the fox crate between them. Other than a quick glance, Siegfried keeps his gaze on the animal as he speaks. In contrast, Audrey searches his face. When Siegfried finally looks up at Audrey, his expression is a breathtaking mix of pleading and promise. (Anyone who’s not already sobbing will start at this point.) A characteristic hard blink confirms Siegfried is wrestling with strong emotions, and he quickly looks away.
Audrey immediately blurts the most natural words for her: “I’m sorry.” Unlike her explicit apology to Bosworth in “Pair Bond,” Audrey’s supposed offense against Siegfried remains unspoken for a long moment. Siegfried looks uncomfortable, wrinkling his brow and shifting his posture. He moves from leaning, looking down with crossed arms, to standing upright, looking at Audrey with an almost outstretched hand. She also fidgets, forcing a tight smile, before saying: “I should never have fed him.” Siegfried shakes his head as if to dispel his earlier rebuke, and almost whispers: “It’s all right.” He looks away and again keeps his eyes on the fox. Samuel West’s performance is as powerful in his silences as in his agonizingly tender delivery of his unpretentious lines.
Sharing Sorrow
Siegfried’s merciful response relieves Audrey of the weight of his judgment. Still burdened with grief, she sighs heavily and turns to sit on the couch. For an instant, her mind is clear enough to recall that she is missing Jimmy’s birthday tea. As the frame widens, we see that Siegfried has even provided heat to aid the fox’s chances of healing. He reassures Mrs. Hall that James and Helen understand her absence. As Audrey accepts this respite from forced merriment, she sinks onto the couch, still sighing heavily. Alternating frames show Audrey, in profile, sitting, and Siegfried, also in profile, standing. While her gaze is unfocused, he stares at her. His ragged inhale suggests he is also lost but determined to stay in this uncomfortable space with Audrey, whatever comes.
Neither Siegfried nor viewers could be prepared for the wave of pain that floods out as Audrey finally opens up about Edward. Tender music begins as Mrs. Hall describes the images of Edward that haunt her. Their positions require Mrs. Hall to lift her eyes to look at Mr. Farnon. This staging and the softly backlit profile shot make her words seem prayer-like. The scene cuts to Siegfried, who silently absorbs the words. Audrey glances up at him once more before her eyes lose outward focus, as though she’s seeing only her thoughts.
The framing remains on Audrey, allowing viewers to witness Anna Madeley’s stunning portrayal of pain. She calculates every head movement, lip pinch, eye shift, and vocal inflection perfectly to expose Audrey’s wounds. Even as Audrey begins to reveal self-conscious thoughts about her hope being “ridiculous” or “unrealistic,” the focus remains on her profile. The emotionality of this scene is absorbing, and the flashback to Edward’s send-off feels intrusive. While the intent may be to mimic Audrey’s insistent mental images, this second flashback in “All God’s Creatures” is not strictly needed to enhance the emotional impact. The poignant words and Madeley’s masterful performance are more than sufficient.
The scene closes with a shot focusing on Audrey’s tear-stained profile. Her fleeting, strained smiles remind us that Siegfried is still there, out of frame. Like viewers, he has had the exquisite and rare privilege of viewing Audrey’s turbulent inner world.
Now streaming on PBS: What are your thoughts on Audrey opening up to Siegfried in All Creatures Great and Small’s “All God’s Creatures?” Let us know in the comments below.
First Featured Image Credit: ©PBS